No to the judge cause he actually showed remorse after what red said is right he literally told red that he was right

Gale: She lost her redeeming qualities in favor of being a queen greedy and become a power-hungry and sick genocidalHowever, I feel that yourHowever, I feel that its endingHowever, I feel that its ending was played with a little sympathy, but very little although it is somewhat entertaining.

Neither Flyer: He definitely counts he's a flat bully which is hateful and pathetic

Judge: No, he is redeemed

I couldn't delete the repeated answer I replaced it with this

Gale: She lost her redeeming qualities in favor of being a queen greedy and become a power-hungry and sick genocidalHowever, I feel that yourHowever, I feel that its endingHowever, I feel that its ending was played with a little sympathy, but very little although it is somewhat entertaining.

Neither Flyer: He definitely counts he's a flat bully which is hateful and pathetic

Judge: No, he is redeemed

Gale: She lost her redeeming qualities in favor of being a queen greedy and become a power-hungry and sick genocidalHowever, I feel that yourHowever, I feel that its endingHowever, I feel that its ending was played with a little sympathy, but very little although it is somewhat entertaining.

Neither Flyer: He definitely counts he's a flat bully which is hateful and pathetic

Judge: No, he is redeemed

Sorry, the answer was repeated, I will delete all but one

I’m not sure about gale being a hate sink but she subverts her minor moment of sympathy by continuing her villany in the games which take place after the cartoon

Neiderflyer was confirmed to just be comic relief so he doesn’t count and judge peckinpah redeems himself and was meant to be funny

Ella: She bullied Red throughout his childhood by calling him "Eyebrows" because of the large size of his eyebrows, and when Red asks the daycare teacher when Mighty Eagle will return, she asks him if his parents told him Mighty Eagle isn't real. She also got away with her cruel actions so she's a Karma Houdini.

Definitely not Pekinpah since he redeemed himself, Gale seems to be too complex overall to be a HS, know nothing about the latter two.

The judge felt remorse and redeemed himself therefore he doesn't qualify not sure about the others though